Monday, May 29, 2006

The Return

Hey. I'm back for another round of Summertime Blues. This summer I'll be trying to do something I've wanted to for a while - reviews of movie trailers. I'm not sure what format these reviews will take, or if they'll true "reviews" at all. For now, I think I'll keep my options open. I posted a bunch of my academic stuff on April 27th or so, so if you're interested in that, just zoom over to that date. All those papers got As, I'll have you know.

Thursday, April 27, 2006

Sundance 2006 Festival Report

House of Sand

The initial shots in House of Sand are breathtaking sand dunes that stretch for miles. Very slowly, specks of people appear in the frame, making their way through the desert at an excruciatingly slow pace. My first association was with Lawrence of Arabia and its similar sprawling desert imagery. It becomes clear, however, that House of Sand relates to Lawrence in a visual sense only. Instead of an epic tale,
House of Sand concerns itself with one family. It is 1910, and Aurea and her aging mother (Fernanda Torres and Fernanda Montenegro, respectively) have been dragged to a remote piece of land in the desert by Aurea's husband, who obviously suffers from alcoholism and is abusive. When he dies, Aurea and her mother are forced to adapt to the desert when their frequent attempts to escape are thwarted.

Indeed, this is the recurring and primary theme of the film: adaptation. For Aurea, the desert is a prison. She longs to return to civilization, and clings to it with photographs and other things from her past. Her mother, on the other hand, grows to like the desert, where "men don't tell her what to do." Aurea eventually comes to see the desert as her home, but it is a process that takes at least ten years, and it could be argued that it takes her entire life. In a particularly touching scene that closes the film, Aurea is visited by her daughter Maria, who informs her mother that man has landed on the moon. "What did they find up there?” she asks, and the answer is nothing but sand." In conclusion, the film seems to argue that a quiet existence without the influence of society is at least equal to a modern one; hence the final example of sophisticated technology being used to find something already in reach of these women since 1910.

Sexuality also receives an interesting treatment in House of Sand. Aurea sleeps with Luis, an Air Force cadet she meets in the desert, after knowing him for only a few hours, Shortly thereafter, she sleeps with Massu, a man of the desert she has known for ten years. These actions can be seen to represent Aurea's attitude toward the desert: she sleeps with Luis, a representative of the civilized world, because she pines for a return to civilization. Her finally sleeping with Massu takes place after her mother has died, and represents her final acceptance of the land she unwillingly (until now) finds herself attached to. Another implication is made about sexuality in this scene: a young Maria, Aurea's daughter, spots her mother and Massu making love. The next scene fast forwards ten or so years, and displays an older Maria as a promiscuous teenager, constantly drunk and smoking. A particularly unsettling event occurs when Maria stumbles upon a camp run by Luis, who has returned to the desert after many years to seek dead Air Force pilots. Maria, drunk, sleeps with Luis, who cannot understand why he has met a girl with the exact likeness or the one he met so many years ago.

This fact is enhanced by the fact that Maria is played by Fernanda Torres, who played Aurea in the scenes ten years prior. This is an interesting practice. Fernanda Torres ends up playing two generations of these women, while Fernanda Montenegro plays three; in the final scene, she plays Maria and Aurea simultaneously. This choice, while undoubtedly playing on the popularity of these two actresses, also serves to enhance the theme of adaptation. Aurea grows to resemble her mother, who was at peace with the desert when she herself comes to the same conclusion, and finally, the same is true for Maria. The sprawling (yet intimate) cinematography, which captured the desert as a place to both love and revile, and the concise and effective screenwriting made House of Sand an exceptional film.

Somebodies

Somebodies is a film that originated in Athens, Georgia from the mind of an African-American University of Georgia student named Hadjii. Billed as an innovate film that is about blacks, but not about drugs, the ghetto, athletes, or any other stereotypica1 material, Somebodies has been receiving a positive buzz from critics like Roger Ebert. I was quite excited to see Somebodies after Ebert gave it such praise. The buzz surrounding Somebodies is not entirely truthful. Somebodies is not a film with characters who simply happen to be black, but (far more interestingly) a film that deals with black culture in a unique way that eschews (and pokes fun at) the various stereotypes found in most “black films.”

Somebodies' first mission, however, is to get laughs, and is entirely successful on this front. Though a few jokes suffer from poor pacing, and it is at times obvious that this is the first film from Hadjii, most of the material is spot on. Some of the funniest scenes in the film involve Scottie, the main character, being dragged by his girlfriend to a meet of a super upbeat group of “Campus Christians for Christ,” whose church service involves new-age hymns with squeaky clean lyrics Scottie can't help but roll his eyes at. I was surprised how well this particular set of scenes played here in Salt Lake City. Perhaps it is because, Somebodies, though often poking fun at both black and white church services, obviously has a real love for religion. Hadjii confirmed this at the post-screening Q&A, where he remarked he'd grown up in the church and praised it for helping people in their times of need, which is what Somebodies is really about.

Hadjii described his characters, who are somewhere between high school and the real world, as “in a transitional period.” Scottie, though initially stubborn about listening to the advice of his wild-eyed reverend, eventually comes to cut back on his drinking and start to make something of his life. Shot on video, Somebodies has a gritty feel that is enhanced by a few short scenes strewn throughout the film of Athens street performers, who bring their own flavor to the film. Though at times obviously the work of a first time director, Somebodies is a film with keen insight into topics of race, youth, and religion, and shows much promise.

Stephanie Daley

Stephanie Daley is a film about two women experiencing the psychological effects of pregnancy and childbirth. I read a similar to description to the one above when I bought my tickets for this film, but it does little justice to the complexity and weight of the material and performances. Stephanie Daley is a high schooler on trial for murder; after having sex at a party, refusing to acknowledge her pregnancy and giving birth in a toilet stall. Lydie Crane, a psychologist who is on her second pregnancy after her first was stillborn, is assigned to Stephanie.

The film is structured in parallel; Stephanie will reveal something about her past, then Lydie will go through a similar situation in her life. Though the structure is relatively simple, the real complexity of the film lies in the lives of these women. Aspects of high school, such as parties, classes, and the general state of perpetual anxiety Stephanie feels while at school is incredibly accurate, and leagues above most high school dramas. Lydie, while coming across as self-assured and adult while with Stephanie, finds plenty of anxiety in her own life, and at times acts as childish as Stephanie: a telling moment occurs when she visits a mall and gets her ear pierced at a kids shop. The smallest moments throughout both lives continue to bear this level of complexity. Things are never black and white. Stephanie is date-raped, but is she? Her maybe-rapist does seem to get her consent, but she barely nods and makes a small noise. Is she consenting, or whimpering? Lydie finds an earring that does not belong to her in her home. Is her husband having an affair? We never find out, and that’s not the point: it is simply for Lydie to decide whether she wants to stay with him.

Stephanie Daley is the second film of the festival I have seen that is shot on video. The cinematography complemented the themes quite well. In scenes of emotional chaos, the camerawork was also chaotic, while in more reflexive situations, such as the sessions between Stephanie and Lydie, the cinematography and editing slowed down. Many shots were taken through glass, delivering a confined feeling. There were a few instances in the film that seemed to be building to some grand conclusion but were then discarded. A teacher in Stephanie’s school treated a student very unfairly, but this was never again touched on and seemed not to have any thematic value. There was also a blood motif running through Lydie’s story (she accidentally cut her finger, had a conversation about Bloody Marys and was called a “Bloodhound”), but this never seemed to resolve itself. This seemed like an effort on the part of the screenwriter to fit too much into the story at times. However, this is a minor quibble, and Stephanie Daley was my favorite film at the festival.

Moonshine

Moonshine was initially the film I was most excited to see at Sundance, for two reasons. First, it’s a vampire film, a subject near and dear to my heart. Second, and more importantly, it was directed by a 20-year old for less than ten thousand dollars. Aside from feeling a bit depressed about being the same age and not having a film under my belt, I was excited to see what this guy had accomplished. The film was shot on digital video, and varies wildly in visual quality from scene to scene. Some scenes are lit exceptionally, perfectly evoking the lurking dread of a much more expensive horror film. Others lack this fine-tuned lighting, and display the murky lifelessness inherent in many digital efforts. The script serves to get the job done, but doesn’t display any particular standout lines. The same can be said for most of the performances in the film, which is understandable, as the majority of the actors are simply people the director recruited from his hometown. Impressive, really, is the fact that these actors rarely descend into complete amateur mode, especially considering the seriousness with which they must talk about subjects like vampirism.

Finally, Moonshine is to be praised for actually trying to raise some real life issues, despite being a horror film. Characters discuss breaking out of their situations, display ambivalence about their daily decisions, and betray a surprising level of complexity. In the end, though, I feel like I may be cutting Moonshine a fair amount of slack for the fact it was directed by such a young man. Certainly, he deserves recognition for the skill and pure effort required to put together a feature length film, but I can’t help wondering whether his age was taken into account when Sundance made its selections, and whether other, better films were not selected because of it.

The Trials of Darryl Hunt

The Trials of Darryl Hunt is one of the stories we hear about so often these days: a man wrongfully imprisoned for murder is found through modern forensic methods to be innocent. This documentary succeeds admirably on a number of levels: putting a face to these cases we hear so much about, examining racism and its part in Darryl’s initial conviction and subsequent trials, and painting a picture of the 20-year struggle of the city of Winston-Salem, North Carolina, where the events of the film take place.

Darryl’s first trial took place in 1984, and the directors of the film noted they had been following his case for ten years. That leaves a period from 1984 to about 1996 where they had no footage of their own. However, it is clear they went to extensive effort in assembling a huge amount of material to work with, and nearly always find an appropriate piece of TV newsreel or similar to cover the underlying situation. Present day interviews are from a technical point of view well-lit and framed. They also serve to clearly and chronologically tell Darryl’s tale without an overarching “voice of God” narrator. The film gains great credibility in my mind by interviewing not only those champions of Darryl, but those on the other side, such as his initial prosecutors, who have a chance to defend their actions.

Once we reach about 1996, we begin to have a much more intimate view of those struggling to free Darryl. One hero that emerges is Mark Rable, who was assigned to defend Darryl in 1984 with no prior experience in high crimes. Despite being assigned only to the initial trial by the court, Mark stayed with Darryl to the end. Mark betrays more emotion on-camera than any other person in the film, once breaking into tears after a failed appeal. Another hero that stays with Darryl from day one is Larry Little, a local Winston-Salem preacher who organizes a fund to pay for Darryl’s defense. The person we don’t get to see during this entire process, of course, is Darryl Hunt, who was locked away for most of the film. The film concerns itself more with the legal aspects of his trials than his personal life, though it could be argued his life was his trials for two decades. According to the filmmakers, there is a four hour DVD which delves more deeply into Darryl’s life, but I think they made the right choice by dealing with the legal implications behind the case in the cut screened at Sundance, making the ordeal more universal.

After the film, Larry Little talked about Darryl’s need to “establish his leadership skills.” What he meant is that Darryl is a very soft-spoken, shy man, probably due in no small measure to not being an environment where he could develop. Regardless, I submit that Darryl simply screen this film wherever he goes, and the audience will follow him to any end. That’s high praise, but I think this film deserves it. Far and away the most important documentary I saw at Sundance, and probably the best.

Tis Autumn – The Search for Jackie Paris

In my original notes for Tis Autumn, I wrote, “a structural mess or the victim of my short attention span?” We had just come out a film, and had nary a break to catch our cinematic breath before this one began. However, upon reflection, I can confirm that Tis Autumn – The Search for Jackie Paris is, regrettably, a structural mess. The narrator of Tis Autumn is the director, Raymond de Fellita. He recounts discovering a few rare tracks from an obscure jazz singer named Jackie Paris, and eventually meets Paris and begins filming him. I suspect the production of the film was very haphazard, because the film itself is very jumbled. Interviews with Paris, as well as various music critics, fellow musicians, and family members lack a unified visual technique: some people appear to the right of the frame, some to the left; some are captured by a shaky handheld camera on the street, while others have the benefit of sitting. Unfortunately, they are all unified by a lack of adequate lighting. One singer interviewed at a carnival looked positively horrible, lit from the side with a harsh light. It would be one thing if this was some undercover investigative report, but it is clear these interviews were planned ahead of time, with plenty of time for lighting.

Shoddy lighting and non-cohesive interviews are not the only thing that mar Tis Autumn. Fellita begins to tell us about Paris’ life, chronologically. But then, he will randomly stop to show us a scene of him and Paris going on a walk, for example. One of these walks contained a conversation about how great it would be if the movie was distributed, so Paris could make some money off the soundtrack. I found this conversation to be highly unprofessional to have in the first place, much less to be kept in the final cut of the film. Another conversation takes place at a record exchange, where Fellita searches for more Paris recordings. A record collector says to Fellita, “I hope your movie gets on PBS!” Again, this line has nothing to do with Jackie Paris and is unprofessional to be left in the film. After the film, Fellita was asked what he felt the message of his film was. He wasn’t sure. I felt the question was unnecessary: the film itself made that clear.

In The Pit

In The Pit is a chronicle about some of the individuals building a bridge in Mexico City. Throughout the construction, four people are traced, speaking their minds about various topics: the bridge itself, but also about life in Mexico, politics, and eventually God, love, family, and philosophy. Two of the individuals studied are two friends: “Shorty” and “Grande.” Grande finds himself on the job after quitting the mafia. He’s very pessimistic, and calls life working on the bridge hell. Shorty is his exact opposite: a man who loves life, and is full of emotion, at one point nearly crying when his co-workers present him with a birthday cake.

The film was shot on a combination of HD, 35, and 16 millimeters. Much care was obviously spent on composition, and every shot is impressive in some way, especially the time lapse photography and the final shot in the film, a 5-minute shot surveying the huge stretch of bridge via helicopter. The most telling moments in the film occur when the hard working protagonists ruminate on their dire circumstances while huge billboards for American products loom in the background. Also of note is the soundtrack: in a Q&A session after the film, the composer revealed that all the music (which was quite beautiful) was comprised entirely of sounds culled from the construction zone: jackhammers, for example, provided the beat. In The Pit was a highly impressive film that gave viewers a unique insight on Mexico City.

An Unreasonable Man

An Unreasonable Man is a documentary that details the political life of Ralph Nader. Comprised mainly by interviews with a vast number of important figures in the life of Nader, including Nader himself, An Unreasonable Man is extremely professional looking. Though it clocks in at almost three hours, the film was very taut, and only seemed to drag during the discussion of Nader’s 2004 presidential campaign, as the 2000 campaign seemed to be the real climax of the story. The film is obviously pro-Nader, and makes little attempt to seem unbiased. The only counter-argument to Nader’s 2000 campaign decisions, for example, come from a political pundit whose arguments seem laughably absurd.

However, the film largely backs up Nader’s controversial decisions with solid fact and impressive reasoning on the part of Nader and his supporters. Occasionally, however, sweeping strings rise on the soundtrack when the film is detailing a particularly impressive move by Nader. I found this soundtrack decision felt very disingenuous, and wished the facts were allowed to stand alone without music obviously made to make your heart swell with emotion. Overall, however, An Unreasonable Man was extremely professional, informative, and entertaining.

Cinnamon

Billed as daring and experimental, Cinnamon is actually simply a poorly made film. The film concerns itself with African-American drag racing, and centers around a few members of the drag racing community. It is shot on what seems to be a consumer level DV camera; which is not in itself inherently bad, seeing how Sundance is a forum for independent filmmakers with little to no budget. However, no attempt is made to improve the image with lighting or interesting composition, nor does there seem to be any attempt at sound mixing. Pitch varies wildly from shot to shot, and characters are often almost inaudible. The film is a fictional narrative, but it is shot as if it is a documentary. Though this approach often leads to interesting and authentic feeling films, in Cinnamon’s case, it falls flat. Characters have so few lines they have no emotional draw, which ends up being unimportant, because nothing really happens to them anyway. They work on their cars, then race, then work some more. However, we are not even treated to seeing them race; the film cuts to unrelated scenes as the races begin. At only 71 minutes, this film, with so little to hold on to, felt like it would drag on forever. I feel as if Cinnamon is a case of pure lazy filmmaking hiding under the cloak of “experimental.”

The Descent

The Descent was a surprising film to see at Sundance from the opening titles: as the Lion’s Gate logo appeared on screen, surprised murmuring filled the theater: had it been picked up for distribution before the festival even started? The surprises continued as the film progressed. One of the few films I saw shot on film, The Descent is a slick, relatively high budget horror film, with few pretensions at being anything other than gory and shocking. The Descent follows a group of women from the U.K. who go on an annual camping trip. This trip involves exploring an uncharted cave formation somewhere in North Carolina. In the cave, the women run into creatures resembling Gollum from Lord of the Rings, except they eat people. After a series of bloody deaths, only one woman makes her way back outside, but then suffers her own fate in a sudden shock ending. Although The Descent was not typical Sundance fare, it succeeded admirably on its own playing field, making the rowdy audience scream and howl an impressive amount of times. Being somewhat callous in terms of horror films, I was surprised at how many times The Descent made me jump. The acting was adequate at best, but the gore effects were convincing, and the lighting added to the fright level, as did the cinematography. Though not as brain stimulating as other films I saw at Sundance, The Descent succeeded on its own terms.

M*A*S*H and A Very Long Engagement: Life During Wartime

The films M*A*S*H and A Very Long Engagement, despite having similar subject matter, are on the surface two wholly different films. A Very Long Engagement is a lush, melodramatic portrait of love enduring through the first World War. M*A*S*H, on the other hand, is a callous, cynical depiction of a mobile army hospital in Korea, filled with Robert Altman’s “smart-ass tendencies.”3 Though Jean Pierre Jeunet and Robert Altman employ wholly different strategies, they come to surprisingly similar conclusions about the horrors of war and the way humans cope with those horrors.

A Very Long Engagement displays its views on war most clearly through its use of color. The World War I of the film is a drab, grey affair that is “almost closer to black and white than color.”1 This lifeless palette serves to display the feeling of suffering and death present in the trenches. Beyond simple black and white, Jeunet strived for a certain color “between green and yellow” to make the mud particularly “wet and disgusting”1. This color palette’s effectiveness is doubled because of the other color palette used in the film. The post and pre-war sequences are richly lit, with a golden tone that makes everything feel warm and idyllic. The contrast between these warm scenes, meant to represent life without war, and the utter cold of life during wartime serves to make the war even more dreadful.

Jeunet also employed a unique style of composition for the film, in which he “tried to avoid imagination, [and] use only references,”1 taking many of his shots directly from photographs of the period. Two examples he points out are the broken Christ figure at the beginning of the film, and the corpse hanging from the tree later on. This brings to the film a real sense of authenticity, and a sense that Jeunet is not simply devising by himself the horrors we witness throughout the film: indeed, these events did occur. Finally, Jeunet employed one more unique stylistic technique: using “only short lenses”1. This allows the camera to focus not only on the character, but “see everything behind the character”1. Jeunet uses this deep focus to show every aspect of the trenches: no horrifying detail is spared, further reinforcing the idea of war as terrible.

The effects of war in A Very Long Engagement are not seen only from a visual perspective. The effect of the war psychologically is displayed most clearly in the character Mathidle, played by Audrey Tautou. Mathidle deals with her grief by clinging to the remote possibility that her fiancĂ©, who was sent off to war years ago, is still alive, and moreover, actively searching for him, even after his gravesite is found. She also plays games of faith with herself, telling herself, “if the dog walks in before supper, Manech is still alive.” This way of dealing with her loss is discouraged by her friends and family as being generally unhealthy until they too get wrapped up in the detective story that Mathidle unravels, and it is perhaps only because the film is a classic melodrama that Manech does survive. This notion, that people cope with war by distracting themselves because the real truth is too terrible to bear, will come into play in a big way in M*A*S*H.

M*A*S*H, one of Robert Altman’s few commercial successes, makes no attempt to follow a traditional dramatic structure in the way A Very Long Engagement does. Despite that, or perhaps because it is free of traditional storytelling restraints, M*A*S*H is able to display a significant view on war. One of the methods Altman uses to reveal his thoughts on war is the use of the “omnipresent”3 loudspeaker in the camp. Though the speaker initially broadcasts fairly standard messages, it soon delves into more “humorous pronouncements”3, such as calls to return stolen amphetamines and a warning that marijuana has been found to be a dangerous drug. This also serves to point out how many (including, we assume, our heroes, since they, as doctors, would have access) turn to drug use to distract themselves from the horror of war. This sentiment is also present in our heroes’ obsession with a good martini, going so far as to carry a jar of olives all the way to the front lines.

Altman does not use the loudspeaker only to point out the rampant drug use in the camp, however. In other scenes, the speaker announces upcoming films. Inevitably, they are all war films, specifically, “all real war movies about World War II.”3 These announcements come with silly ad-copy for this films, like “a story so big only the biggest screens can bring it to you,” all read in a flat, monotone expression. The humor of these pronouncements, which make serious war films sound ridiculous, serves to make war itself sound ridiculous. The fact that these propagandistic films are being shown to those experiencing the real horror on the front lines piles the irony even higher.

The firmest opposition to the concept of the military (and by association, war) comes from M*A*S*H’s main characters, specifically, Hawkeye and Trapper John. By constantly and consistently making a mockery of the “rigid military establishment”2, they clearly signal their disdain for all things war. Their humor in dire circumstances also serves to keep them sane in what they consider an insane situation. This penance for humor shows itself from the very beginning of the film onward. When Hawkeye first arrives, he is mistaken for a jeep driver. Instead of correcting the mistake, he “[senses] the potential humor” and “throws himself into the role of chauffeur”2. Here, Hawkeye shows utter disdain for his rank and role in the military, just as soon opting for the rank of chauffeur as captain. Later, when Hawkeye and Trapper John are in Japan, they scam, cheat, and “constantly outwit”2 those running the hospital, again showing blatant disregard for rank or duty.

However, Hawkeye and Trapper John do care about their job: saving lives. Hawkeye’s sincerity about good medical work is evident when he complains to Hot Lips about Frank Burns’ lack of skill. Though he dislikes the man personally, he takes even greater offense to Burns being a danger to wounded men. The scenes in which Hawkeye and company are shown operating display both their conviction and the way in which they cope with their insane surroundings. Altman makes the repulsiveness of the situation clear by having “veins pop and guts flow”2 in a fairly gruesome fashion. Among this gore, Hawkeye and co. joke endlessly, flirting with nurses and singing choruses in unison. This coping device is given full approval by Altman: his heroes joke and survive, while those who practice deadly seriousness, like Major Burns, are hauled off in strait jackets.

The ways in which A Very Long Engagement and M*A*S*H differ are numerous. One of the most significant is structure. A Very Long Engagement follows typical dramatic structure: though noteworthy for its flashbacks, which blend war and peace, the film features rising action, a climax, and so on. M*A*S*H is set up differently. Instead of one two-hour story, the film is simply a series of non-related events that happen over the course of some undefined time in the camp. Traditional form is thrown out the window: the main characters do not fundamentally change in any way, nor face any daunting task. Beginning, middle, and end are barely relevant; only the action of Hawkeye arriving and leaving serve to tack bookends to the film.

Another major difference between the two films is tone. A Very Long Engagement is highly melodramatic, with sweeping strings and emotional close-ups. This is especially true in the love scenes between Manech and Mathilde. Though the film does not romanticize war, it is otherwise highly romantic, especially with the idea of searching for a loved one who is almost certainly dead. M*A*S*H, on the other hand, seems to take a much more callous view of human behavior. Romance, in the traditional sense, does not exist. “Painless” Waldowski, for example, cheats on the three women he has at home by sleeping with Lt. Dish, who is betraying her husband by doing so. Even Burns, who is married and professes to be deeply religious, sleeps with O’Houlihan. Certainly, none of the characters in M*A*S*H would wait three years hoping for the love of their life to return from the dead.

What is amazing, then, despite all these differences, is how similar a view both films take on war. First, of note, is the wars in which they are set. Both World War I and the Korean War (or Vietnam, depending on whether you decide to take M*A*S*H literally or figuratively) are not heroic struggles on the scale of World War II. Rather, they are regarded as pure wastes of human life. While the soldiers in Saving Private Ryan may be heroes, the soldiers we are presented with in these films have no illusions of heroism. We see men mutilate themselves to go home in A Very Long Engagement: obviously, they are more concerned with themselves than their country. Another telling moment occurs in the same film when the trench leader yells, “For France!” and receives utter silence from his men in return.

The most obvious connection these two films have to each other is that they are explicitly anti-war. In fact, put together, they serve to show the effects of war on a multitude of different people: those fighting the battles, their loved ones who hope for a safe return, and those who treat the wounded, who, we assume as we watch Hawkeye work, are more concerned with the aforementioned loved ones than returning the wounded to the battlefield.

Also tying A Very Long Engagement and M*A*S*H are the attitudes its characters take toward war. Though searching for a lost love and making dirty jokes in the operating room hardly seem like the same thing, they are both strategies used by their respective characters to keep their minds from the horror before them. The implication in both films is that war, taken at face value without distracting oneself from its true nature, is too horrifying to stand. To show us this is the case, both films display characters to which this has happened: Manech and his four compatriots, who willingly destroy a part of their own bodies to get out, and Major Burns, who is removed in a strait jacket because he is not able to joke his way through war like Hawkeye.

A Very Long Engagement and M*A*S*H are two films that would not typically been seen together in any context but a very comprehensive list of war films. However, the radical differences between the two make for a much more interesting comparison: what do two filmmakers separated by structure, tone, and more than thirty years have to say about war? In the case of Jeunet and Altman, they come to surprisingly similar conclusions: that war is hell, and that people cope with that hell the best they can.

Bibliography

1“French Director Jean Pierre Jeunet.” Fresh Air. NPR. WHYY, Philadelphia. 12 Jan.
2005. http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=4280683.

2Feineman, Neil. Persistence of Vision: The Films of Robert Altman. New York: Arno Press, 1978.

3Karp, Alan. The Films of Robert Altman. New Jersey: The Scarecrow Press, Inc., 1981.

Unified participation versus inactive voyeurism in The Cow

The townspeople in Dariush Mehrjui’s The Cow have their fair share of problems. On a good day, they are constantly being watched by a strange group of marauders. On a bad day, the town’s only cow dies of an unknown cause. And on a really bad day, that cow’s owner starts to believe he himself is his dead cow. As the town tries to work through its problems, two types of behavior emerge: active participation and watching from afar. Mehrjui uses sound design and composition to propose that in a community such as this, active unified participation is essential to survival, while inactive voyeurism is at best useless, and at worst harmful.

In the very first scene of The Cow, we pay witness to the voyeuristic aspects of the town at their harshest. The film opens with a multitude of tight, unmoving shots of townspeople staring intently at the camera. Even a dog is shown absolutely unmoving and unblinking, staring straight ahead. Finally, it is revealed what they are staring at. The town’s children, led by Saffar, the resident bully, are torturing a man soon revealed to be mentally disabled. Most of the townspeople simply watch as Saffar smears what may be paint or blood all over his face, bring burning sticks dangerously close to him, and run him into the town well. Only one adult tells them to stop, and no attention is paid to his command. In this scene, framing is tight. There is often only one face in picture at a time. This serves to show a lack of town unity; as the townspeople are not united in stopping Saffar, nor are they united physically in the frame.

In contrast to the opening scene, a much more unified town appears when Hassan’s wife delivers the news that Hassan’s cow has died. When Hassan’s wife suffers her nervous breakdown and cries in the middle of the town, everyone rushes to her aid, offering prayers and helping her calm down. This scene establishes both Eslam, the de facto town leader and champion of active participation, and the unnamed man in the window, the pinnacle of voyeurism. Aside from him, the town is almost wholly unified in this scene, and the filmmaking reflects it. As Eslam and others try to decide what to do about the cow, they are framed less closely than previously: several people, working together, are in frame together. Because of this town unification, they are able to come to a solution regarding Hassan’s cow. The final evidence of this achievement comes when the men of the town pull the cow into the well. This scene displays a fully unified town. The only thing audible on the soundtrack is the men’s simultaneous “heave-ho” sounds, showing how total physical and mental unification can move an object one man could not move alone.

Shortly thereafter, however, the town unity seen here is shattered. When Hassan returns, so does the town’s voyeuristic aspect. This is immediately apparent in the contrast between the sound design of this scene and the cow burial scene preceding it. When Hassan returns, the town goes virtually silent. Visually, Mehrjui signals the voyeuristic dominance of the scene by showing the man in the window as one of the first characters to spot Hassan. His window is framed very two dimensionally, bringing to mind a television, or some other viewing screen. When Hassan passes, each of the townspeople hide behind something in turn, wishing only to watch and not actually interact with Hassan. Even Eslam, the film’s champion for community participation, lies to Hassan when Hassan asks if everything is all right. The concept of window as film screen comes back into play when Hassan’s neighbors look in on him as he begins his initial transformation into cowliness. They are framed in the cow shed’s rectangular window, which by no accident resembles a modern film screen. Through this screen, they watch Hassan for several minutes before finally deciding to go to his aid.

After Hassan descends into his madness, Eslam decides to take action in an ambiguous scene that is neither clearly either unified or voyeuristic in the way previous scenes have been. As the scene opens, women from the town are strewn about an otherwise empty field, praying. They are all in frame at once, yet dispersed, so that communication would be difficult without yelling. The soundtrack, again almost wholly silent (despite the field being very windy), seems to reinforce this chasm of communication. Eslam walks in to find his compatriots sitting around an old structure, doing very little of anything but watching the women. However, the voyeuristic aspect of the scene is tempered by Eslam’s insistence on taking action: he wants to bring Hassan to the city, to get help at the hospital. Two of the men reluctantly agree. This reluctance, combined with the silent soundtrack and voyeuristic imagery, foreshadows Hassan’s doom in the next scene, despite Eslam’s good intention.

Why does the village seemingly flip-flop from helpful to hidden so often? Mehrjui describes the film as “the plight of an individual versus the society around him.” With that theme in mind, one could take a cynical look at the help Eslam and others attempt to provide. When the mentally disabled person is attacked, no one bothers to help, because there is no profit in it for them. In fact, a particularly cruel punishment is served to this man when he is tied up underground later in the film: far away from the town’s action, he is denied even the act of voyeurism. On the other hand, when the cow dies, everyone is concerned because it was their only source of milk. One could also argue the sympathy felt for Hassan is simply borne out of their wish for him to get a new cow and continue his valuable service to the village.

However, it should be noted voyeurism is not the same as disinterest; far from it. Even the notorious man in the window shows a genuine concern for what goes on in the village, even if he seemingly never leaves his home. Mehrjui also states his desire to “catch the essence of village life.” This may be where Mehrjui succeeds most admirably, using composition and sound design to paint a three-dimensional, realistic village: always interested in the plight of their fellow townspeople, but sometimes going about it the wrong way.

Guns and cameras in City of God

The film City of God portrays a slum of Rio de Janeiro where gangs rule by force of arms. Through the decades spanned in the film, Fernando Meirelles displays a cycle of violence, where guns are passed from brother to brother, until the gang members get younger and younger, and all hope of leaving for a better life is lost. The film’s main character, Rocket, escapes this cycle by arming himself not with a gun, but a camera. Though the implicit meaning of the camera is clear, Meirelles draws parallels throughout the film between cameras and guns, emphasizing how close Rocket is at all times to falling into the same cycle of violence as his friends.

Cameras are introduced into Rocket’s life in the scene documenting the City of God’s 1960s era, a bloodbath that climaxes in a photographer taking shots of a corpse. Introducing cameras in this way gives Rocket’s camera use in the rest of the film a sense of morbidity. Rocket’s first camera-as-gun experience happens immediately after the introduction of his first camera, “the world’s cheapest model.” While on the beach, Rocket takes photos of his crush, Angelica. When Tiago, Angelica’s boyfriend, comes in for a group photo, Rocket tells him to move back, casting his face in shadow and essentially removing him from the photo. Though it seems like an innocent bit of teenage jealousy, Rocket’s act takes on a sinister air when similar acts are perpetrated later in the film with guns instead of cameras. Removing people simply because they are annoying seems to be a near-constant theme: at one point, the town’s principal drug lord, Li’l Ze, shoots his loudmouth friend just to get him to “shut up.”

The link between guns and cameras is solidified in the scene where Benny, Li’l Ze’s longtime friend and partner, throws a party before he plans to leave the city. During the party, Benny receives a camera in exchange for a bag of cocaine, and gives it to Rocket. However, Li’l Ze, who is furious at Benny for planning to leave, wrestles the camera from Rocket. While Benny and Li’l Ze are fighting over the camera, a bullet meant for Li’l Ze hits and kills Benny, preventing him from leaving the City of God. Firstly, and most obviously, the camera quite literally has as much to do with Benny’s death as the gun does. It keeps him in close proximity to Li’l Ze, thrashing around so Li’l Ze’s would-be assassin cannot get a clear shot. Also, the camera was traded for cocaine. Since even the gangsters in the City of God are not rich, they buy their guns in the same way; not with money, but with drugs. Finally, the tie between the gun and the camera in this scene is solidified stylistically as well. When the fight between Benny and Li’l Ze heats up moments before Benny is shot, the dance begins to be lit entirely by a strobe light. This has the effect of making the action seem like individual photos being taken one after another.

More interesting parallels are drawn between guns and cameras late in the film, when Li’l Ze and Rocket are both “armed” by respective professionals. While Li’l Ze hosts an arms dealer in his apartment, Rocket is given a job as a photojournalist and is equipped with various pieces of camera machinery. The similarity of these two scenes is striking. Both professionals (the gun salesman and the newspaper photographer) are shown surrounded by their wares, picking up various bits of machinery and explaining them in technical lingo at fast speeds. Both recipients know little about the equipment they’re receiving; Li’l Ze rejects a gun with the “same caliber, but lighter” than the one he wants, while Rocket has to be asked “will you be up close or far away?” so he can be taught what lenses to use. Finally, being up close or far away factors in another way. Rocket definitively states “far away” as far as the question is asked, and for good reason: he does not want to get hit. Li’l Ze has the same request: he specifically asks for a long-range gun with an “infrared sight.”

The final comparison between cameras and guns in City of God comes at the concluding scene of the film. Due to circumstances revolving around a runaway chicken, Rocket finds himself face to face with Li’l Ze’s gang, all brandishing a plethora of guns. On his other side are cops, also ready to fire. In response, Rocket holds up his camera to the gang. In a shot that serves to prove Rocket is completely surrounded, the (movie) camera circles around Rocket’s camera, placing it in comparison to the gun-toting groups throughout the shot: he is wildly outgunned. Then, at the exact moment Rocket takes a photo of the gang, a member of the rival gang appears and shoots one of Li’l Ze’s men. In this instant, the sound of the gun firing and of the camera shutter clicking are as one, further solidifying the link between the two pieces of machinery. Soon afterwards, Rocket jumps and ducks behind a wall in a shot so reminiscent of any war movie. The only difference is instead of a gun, Rocket brandishes a camera from behind his wall, firing off photo after photo of the gang war. Ultimately, Rocket photographs the dead body of the gun-downed Li’l Ze. Before he is killed, Li’l Ze tells his gang members, “we’ll have to do a few hold-ups to get my business going again.” His mind follows a fairly simple track: hold-ups equal money. As Rocket surveys his photos, he has a similar thought: “This picture of the hood will guarantee my salary.”

City of God is primarily a film about a young man who escapes the cycle of violence in his home town by taking up a creative endeavor instead of spiraling into drug abuse and gang membership. Certainly, the film promotes practice. However, as with most good filmmakers, Fernando Meirelles introduces shades of grey where others would leave the issues black and white. Specifically, Meirelles shows a link between guns, which perpetrate the cycle of violence, and cameras, which Rocket uses to break free, though the camera frequently shows Rocket a world as tempting and immoral as that of his friends. In this way, Meirelles illustrates just how close Rocket is at any moment to falling into the same dark life as the rest of his home town.

Style and Theme in Orson Welles’ Touch of Evil

In 1956, Charlton Heston was offered a part in a project titled Badge of Evil. Upon learning Orson Welles was to play the heavy in the picture, Heston suggested to the film’s producers that Welles also direct (Comito, 213). Upon receiving the director’s chair, Welles quickly rewrote the film, moving the film’s location to a small town on the Mexican-American border, changing Heston’s character to a Mexican policeman and his wife to a naĂŻve American girl, and making various other changes to suit the themes he wished to explore (Comito, 183). Thus, Touch of Evil was transformed from a run-of-the-mill gangster film to one of the last and greatest examples of film noir, exploring complex themes about racism, betrayal, and what it means to uphold justice. The complex thematic elements of Touch of Evil are rivaled only by its stylistic ones. From the breathtaking three minute, twenty second unbroken opening shot, today a staple of any introductory film course, Touch of Evil shows Orson Welles at the height of his visual (and aural) power. But the true brilliance of Touch of Evil lies in the combination of the stylistic and the thematic. At all times during the film, they are intertwined and inseparable, feeding off each other and growing more powerful as a result. After Welles completed Touch of Evil, its near-sighted producers found it too confusing and re-edited it, going as far as to shoot new scenes. In 1998, noted editor Walter Murch assembled a new cut of the film based on a 58 page memo Welles wrote after seeing the studio’s version (Ebert). Thanks to Murch’s efforts, we can now examine the stylistic and thematic elements of Touch of Evil with the knowledge that what we are viewing is as close to Welles’ vision as possible.

Perhaps no opening scene in the history of film is as memorable as that of Touch of Evil. A dizzying uninterrupted three minute shot which goes from close-ups to wide angles to everything in-between, Welles’ opening shot is not only a stylistic feat, but helps to reveal much about what is to come as the film progresses. Welles wastes no time revealing the device that will serve as the primary source of tension through the shot: the film opens with an extreme close-up of a time bomb, which the audience sees set to three minutes and placed in a car. In a complex crane and dolly shot, the camera follows the car through the streets of the seedy border town to its inevitable destruction. Because there are no cuts, the tension of the scene is increased dramatically: we know the bomb will explode in three minutes, and we experience those three minutes in real time. During the course of the shot, the car disappears from view several times, occasionally speeding ahead or dragging behind the camera. This also serves to increase tension, because the audience is forced to keep track of the car, hoping desperately it will not disappear before the preordained three minutes are over (Comito, 191).

The doomed car, however, is not the only subject of this shot. It also serves to introduce two of the film’s main characters, Inspector Vargas (Heston) and his newlywed wife Susan (Janet Leigh). Often, when the camera temporarily strays from the car, it is to follow this couple, but it should be noted the car and the couple are never far from each other. There is some dialogue that explains Vargas is a detective, specializing in narcotics, while the woman in the doomed car complains about a ticking noise. Finally, as the camera swoops in to a close-up of Vargas and his wife kissing, the car explodes, and there is finally a cut. This technique serves to tie the explosion and the Vargases together: the sudden fusion of romance and violence makes clear their honeymoon will be marred by this incident (McBride, 152). It also serves to foreshadow the difficulties the Vargases will face as their different cultures collide. Also note that the vehicle explodes immediately after crossing into the United States. Welles begins making a point here from the get-go: that the U.S. side of the border is as dangerous as the Mexican side, if not more. The border motif is one that Welles continues to use throughout the film as one of the many ways he tackles racism.

Finally, there is a bit to be said about the sound design of this shot. When originally released, the studio used it as the film’s credits sequence, placing titles which obstructed key visual elements and using a piece of music by Henry Mancini that, while excellent (as is the case with most of Mancini’s work), defies Welles’ intent for the shot. Welles detailed his plan in his infamous 58 page memo:

As the camera moves through the streets of the Mexican border town, the plan was to feature a succession of different and contrasting Latin American musical numbers – the effect, that is, of our passing one cabaret orchestra after another… [this] was planned as a basic device throughout the entire picture.

Clearly, Welles thought this musical idea not just important for this particular shot, but to establish a mood for the entire film. The effect of Welles’ idea, now restored to us by Walter Murch, is to contrast American rock’n’roll with Mexican mambo-style music, again hinting at the rift (or border) between the two countries, and, more obliquely, Vargas and Susan.

If there is one chief element in Touch of Evil Welles does not introduce in the opening shot, it is perhaps because, as Joseph McBride describes, “Welles the director” was fond of “[delaying] Welles the actor from appearing until we are sufficiently expectant of a grand entrance, an apparition that will transfix our attention” (McBride, 28). Hank Quinlin, the bulbous American “police celebrity” and arguably, the film’s protagonist -- Charlton Heston said, “Touch of Evil is about the decline and fall of Captain Quinlin” (Comito, 215) -- arrives with a certain amount of fanfare. When Vargas states, “I’d like to meet him,” the local coroner (played by longtime Welles associate Joseph Cotton) smirks and replies, “that’s what you think.” In the next shot, Welles as Quinlin emerges from his car, a sweaty, jowly man with a cigar in his mouth. The camera in this shot is very low, emphasizing both Quinlin’s bulk (Welles was padded for the role, his own bulk still in its infancy) and his immense power among those on the U.S. side of the border. This is in sharp contrast to the last shot we saw of Vargas, who occupied only about a quarter of the frame, making clear which police officer is in control of the current situation. Finally, The low-angle shot of Quinlin is significant because he towers over Menzies, his partner, who is both physically shorter than Quinlin and relegated to the corner of the frame. He then calls Menzies a “jackass,” and the film quickly cuts to another scene, leaving Menzies no chance to respond. This cements Quinlin’s domination over Menzies, which comes to play a large role in Menzies’ decision to help Vargas defeat Quinlin later in the film.

Though the shot that opens Touch of Evil is its most famous, it is not the longest, nor perhaps the most interesting. The shot in question takes place 36 minutes into the film, when Quinlin and his cronies, with Vargas in tow, show up at the house of Marcia Linnekar to question her and her Mexican boyfriend, Sanchez. Lasting five minutes and twenty-three seconds and covering a multitude of characters and rooms, this shot was considered by Welles “the greatest use of the moving camera in the history of cinema” (McBride, 150). As usual with Welles, this shot is not purely a stylistic achievement, but also helps enhance the thematic content of the scene. First, the long take provides many of the same elements it did in the film’s opening shot; namely, the tension of real-time. Never is the audience freed from Quinlin’s growling racist remarks by a cut or dissolve; they must endure the embarrassing antics of Sanchez at face value, with no tricks of montage to speed up time. This style of shooting, where the audience’s conclusions about a certain character are not forced by editing and they can “give the image the interpretation of [their] choice” (Comito, 249) is that favored by Andre Bazin, noted film critic and admirer of Welles. Welles leaves much interpretation to the audience in this shot; Quinlin, for example, is not captured at the usual low angle that enhances his bulk and power, but is rather put on equal footing with the other characters. Thus, the audience is freed to take Quinlin’s racist statements (“I don’t speak Mexican”) on their own merit, or lack thereof.

However, calling the interrogation shot a purely Bazinian artifact, where the audience is not manipulated in any way, would not be accurate. Montage is not the only tool Welles wields to influence the audience’s interpretation. For example, this shot is rife with camera movement: over 60 separate movements, to be precise. These movements, in place of montage, direct the viewer where to look. An obvious example is the moment in which Vargas enters the bathroom. The camera follows him in just as he knocks over a shoebox. It then points to the ground, centered on the box, so that the viewer is quite aware the box is empty. This leads us to instantly know Quinlin has framed Sanchez when Menzies finds dynamite in the box – after Quinlin has been in the bathroom himself. Shortly after Vargas knocks over the box, one of Quinlin’s cronies arrives with coffee. As Quinlin asks, “didn’t you bring me any donuts or sweet rolls?” the camera tracks in, displaying Quinlin in a particularly jowly and obese moment. Aside from camera movement, Welles also employs lighting for manipulative effect. With up to nine characters in frame at one time, the mood of the shot is extremely claustrophobic. Welles increases this claustrophobic effect by lighting “from below eye level” and therefore throwing “shadows on the far wall, in effect, doubling the number of figures in the room” (Comito, 191). Finally, Welles’ use of a wide angle lens, the primary function of which is to “hold a number of figures within the frame at one time” also serves to give characters a slightly disquieting effect, making them “loom” at times, like when Quinlin laments his lack of donuts (Comito, 191).

If Welles has so far shown us he is a master of the long take, the scene where he confronts and kills Uncle Joe Grandi shows his mastery of montage. At this point, the plot has advanced to a stage where Vargas is determined to prove Quinlin guilty of corruption. Therefore, Quinlin strikes back, teaming up with Joe Grandi to discredit Vargas by kidnapping his wife and making it seem as if she is addicted to narcotics. This is the scene in which Quinlin’s life slips into chaos, and is thus the most frenetic and disturbing scene of the film. As Quinlin enters the room, he and Grandi stare at the bed where the unconscious Mrs. Vargas lies. They are shot through a baroque and ornate bed post, a disquieting image that suggests everything is not well. Quinlin asks Grandi to turn the light off, transforming the lighting of the scene into a true noir masterpiece. The only light coming into the scene is a blinking neon sign from outside the window, throwing everything into darkness for several seconds at a time. This allows a great deal of suspense as the scene progresses: we must wait for the set to light up to see clearly the violence Quinlin does to Grandi. As Quinlin steps to the opposite side of the bed, the light comes through the window in such a way that Susan’s face is well lit, while Quinlin’s is almost wholly in shadow, again implying the imminent danger faced from Quinlin. As this danger becomes evident to Grandi and Quinlin makes his move, the editing speeds up. With the obscure lighting, distortion caused by the wide angle lens, and rapid fire pace, some critics have argued this scene is “designed solely to shock the spectator (Comito, 253). Jean Collet, however, argues the montage serves a deeper purpose:

It is to prevent the spectator from adhering to a single character; to force him, on the contrary, to be everywhere at once, to play all the contrary games: the satisfaction of Grandi… the machiavellianism of Quinlin… and finally the terror of Susan. (Comito, 253).

Touch of Evil is at all times a complex film with, by all accounts, a “labyrinthe plot” (Ebert) and characters with confusing motivations and personalities, especially that of Hank Quinlin. The conclusion of the film is no relief from that complexity. Quinlin, shot by Menzies, floats away in a slimy canal after attempting to wash Menzies’ blood off his hands, an action McBride calls “an allusion to Macbeth” (McBride, 154), which Welles not-so-incidentally filmed ten years earlier. If anything, Quinlin is, like Macbeth, a “giant destroyed by hubris” (Ebert). Welles himself denounces Quinlin, stating, “Quinlin is the incarnation of everything I struggle against… that’s what I detest above all, men who wish to judge by their own authority” (Comito, 206). Tanya, Quinlin’s old friend, comes to a more apathetic conclusion, stating, “He was some kind of man… what does it matter what you say about people?” as she stalks into the noir-lit streets.

For Orson Welles, like Hank Quinlin, Touch of Evil would be a final effort. Disgruntled with the studio interference on nearly all his films, including Touch of Evil, Welles never made another film in Hollywood, struggling to finance his own films and eventually dying with several projects lingering in various states of completion. Touch of Evil, then, shows us Welles’ last great manipulation of the Hollywood system. Within the bounds of adapting a crime/gangster novel, Welles used all his skill in filmmaking to deliver a deep and complex work covering themes of racism, betrayal, and justice in a border town where issues are never black and white. To explore these themes, Welles created some of the most famous and critically lauded images in the history of cinema, and inspired a new generation of directors like Francois Truffaut and Jean-Luc Godard. For this achievement, Welles deserves only the highest praise.

Works Cited

McBride, Joseph. Orson Welles. New York: Da Capo Press, 1996.

Comito, Terry. Touch of Evil. New Jersey: Rutgers University Press. 1985.

Ebert, Roger. “Touch of Evil.” RogerEbert.com. September 13, 1998. Chicago
Sun-Times. November 29, 2005.

Plato versus Aristotle on Poetry

In his master work The Republic, Plato attempts to create a hypothetical perfect society through discussion between his teacher Socrates and other Greeks. In the course of this discussion, Plato decides poets should be banned from his republic, and goes on to detail why poetry and poets are harmful to humanity. Years later, Plato’s student Aristotle wrote Poetics, a work that defends poetry as a valuable resource. Though these two competing works were written over 2,000 years ago, there is still debate over the danger and value of art. A more thorough analysis of Plato and Aristotle’s views will reveal how these works on poetry apply to today’s realm of popular entertainment.

Plato finds poetry and poets unsavory for two reasons he details in Book X of The Republic. Firstly, he takes issue with the imitative aspect of poetry. He demonstrates how far from reality poetry is by making an analogy to a bed. Socrates defines the most real bed as “the nature of things, bedhood, which we would say God made” (396). From this ideal bedhood comes beds made by craftsmen; Plato believes these are one step from reality. Finally, a painter who paints this bed is labeled “the imitator in the third generation from nature” (397). Socrates and Glaucon chide this painter, who represents the poet in their analogy, for creating “appearances, but not things really existing anywhere” (395) and not having a true grasp on reality. Socrates then directly attacks Homer himself, questioning Homer’s worth because he never helped govern a nation or participated in education.

Plato’s second criticism of poetry deals with the way humans respond to poetry emotionally. Plato describes humans as having two warring parts within them: one that is lead by pure emotion and one that is rational and “ready to obey the law” (404). He gives an example of a man who has lost a son. One half of this man wishes to lament endlessly, while the other half wants to “keep calm and endure.” Plato believes it is this latter half that is “manly” and praiseworthy, but that poets instead favor those who “[chant] and [beat] their breasts,” (406) in order to provoke an unrealistic and fake emotional response, playing on the pity and fear of the audience. He warns that if the men poets praise were in power, “pleasure and pain will be kings in your city, instead of law” (407).

Despite being Plato’s student for twenty years, Aristotle came to have very different opinions than his teacher on a number of issues. In his Poetics, Aristotle takes the defense of the poetry Plato so harshly criticized. He does this particularly in a chapter entitled “The origin and development of poetry.” While he does not argue with Plato’s assertion that poetry is imitative, he draws wholly different conclusions about imitation. Aristotle states, firstly, “the habit of imitating is congenital to human beings from childhood,” and that man in fact “learns his first lessons through imitation” (20). In other words, imitation is not three layers removed from reality, but is an essential part of human existence.

Secondly, Aristotle asserts that humans take pleasure from imitation. He points out that “least favored animals,” while causing pain and fear in reality, are enjoyable when rendered in some form of art. This aspect of art, wherein the audience is able to feel intense emotion without experiencing real danger, is known as catharsis, a cleansing of the emotional palette Aristotle finds healthy. This is in direct opposition to Plato, who believes the emotions experienced through poetry are not in sync with reality, and cause lawlessness.

The debate started by these great minds regarding poetry, the popular entertainment and art of their day, has only increased in intensity since their original writings. Though poetry has been replaced as the dominant form of entertainment, today’s Homers are still beset with wildly divergent opinions on their works. Today’s primary concerns are still twofold: the role of imitation and emotional impact in art. In these matters, my allegiance lies with Aristotle.

At the time of this writing, many lawmakers, officials, and parents are concerned with a relatively new type of art form: the video game. They believe the imitative aspect of games, i.e. the fact players help their onscreen counterparts cause mayhem and destruction, causes these players to recreate their actions in reality. Plato would likely take the side of these concerned citizens. The Grand Theft Auto series, with its car crashes, gang beatings and polygonal prostitutes, practically brings to life Socrates’ remark: “pleasure and pain will be kings in your city, instead of law.” However, Aristotle (and I) would argue for the cathartic aspect of these games; their players take out their frustrations onscreen, and not in the real world. In the year 2004, 5.1 million copies of the latest Grand Theft Auto sequel were sold1. The PC game Doom, which inspired controversy after it was discovered the Columbine shooters were devoted players, was estimated to be installed on 10 million computers in 19952. Though tragedies like Columbine make a lasting impression on the minds of the world, the ratio of supposed video game-inspired incidents of violence versus the number of video game players simply does not favor Plato’s stance. Rather, this ratio points out a public ripe for Aristotle’s catharsis; experiencing an imitation of reality and taking pleasure in releasing emotion. A generation from now, young people will scoff at the notion of video games as dangerous, just as mine scoffs at the idea of rock and roll as subversive devil’s music.

Aristotle also showed more foresight than his teacher in the matter of poetry’s worth to future generations. Plato dismisses poets like Homer, likening them to a holder of a mirror, who creates only appearances, but nothing with true form. He also chides Homer for never having help run a government or an educational facility. In both these matters, Plato shows a stunning lack of prescience. Today, uncountable numbers of classes dealing with forms of literature fill the academies Plato himself helped found. When we say a certain work of art “holds up a mirror to society,” we are praising it for its insight, not scorning it for being a copy of a copy. One can derive a certain amusement to think of Plato’s hypothetical reaction to the recent film Troy – would he consider it an imitation of an imitation of an imitation? Humor aside, we can see in films like Troy the legacy Plato claimed Homer lacked. It is now evident Homer’s contribution is far greater than helping govern one Greek city: he has inspired art, something Aristotle had the foresight to recognize as innate and essential, for over two millennia.

In Plato’s The Republic and Aristotle’s Poetics, we see two great minds of Greece come to different conclusions about two aspects of poetry. Plato regards the imitative property of poetry with dismay, citing its unreal aspects. Aristotle finds this imitation a necessary part of human life. Plato feels the emotional impact of poetry plays on the human psyche, and breeds unlawfulness. Aristotle contends this very emotional impact helps us relieve our tensions in a healthy way. When these views are transposed to a modern context, I cannot help but side with Aristotle.

Low-key Lighting in Modern Film

At the height of the Hollywood studio system, the vast majority of films were lit from above, with smooth, even light illuminating every part of the set equally. This technique is known as high-key lighting. Through the years, intrepid cinematographers began experimenting with lighting positions, discovering new ways to express mood, tone, and emotion by casting shadows, obscuring certain areas of the frame, and increasing contrast. This method came to be known as low-key lighting. Though pioneered as early as the 1920’s in Germany, modern low-key lighting owes a great deal to Gordon Ellis, the so-called ‘Prince of Darkness’ who shot films like The Godfather with particularly low light levels. Since then, low-key lighting has come to dominate modern science fiction and horror films. Particularly adept at following Gordon Ellis’ lead and using this style to great effect in their films are the modern directors Ridley Scott and David Cronenberg.

Ridley Scott’s Alien is consistently listed on the top of critics’ horror film lists. The highly claustrophobic and chilling atmosphere of this film is created largely by the way Scott and his cinematographer, Derek Vanlint, employ low-key lighting techniques. Consider a scene early in the film in which a few crew members land on an uninviting alien world and are forced to wear space suits into a foreboding crashed vessel. Scott and Vanlint’s lighting technique is particularly ingenious here. The crew members’ faces are actually lit by on-screen lights; that is, their space suits are equipped with flashlights which serve both the story and the production. These lights make visible the frightened space travelers while not illuminating the rest of the set, allowing the vessel to be dark and mysterious. The lights also beat down on the travelers in a harsh way, casting shadows on their faces and making them seem very small in their suits, enhancing the feeling of claustrophobia felt by the characters and the audience.

The scene in which the ship’s captain, Dallas, attempts to hunt down the alien in a small corridor allows Scott and Vanlint to again use low-key lighting in an inventive and horrifying way. Dallas, played by Tom Skerritt, is lit primarily by objects that appear on-screen: a flashlight and a flamethrower. Again, we see props in the film used for a dual purpose; both to serve the story and provide lighting. The way Skerritt holds the flashlight allows the light to hit his face from below, casting large and ominous shadows through the corridor, a textbook low-key technique. Also, the flamethrower flickers about the corridor, casting light at irregular intervals, allowing but the briefest glimpses at what lies ahead for Dallas, increasing the tension of the scene.

Many consider Ridley Scott’s next film Blade Runner a futuristic revival of film noir, a genre practically defined by low-key lighting. Let us visit the scene in which Harrison Ford’s character Deckard is briefed by his boss on the newly escaped replicants roaming the streets of L.A. In this scene, Deckard and his boss sit in a room lit by neon, which makes the entire room a harsh, dark shade of blue. Additionally, they are hit from behind with a hard white light to produce a glaring halo effect. With this setup, Scott and cinematographer Jordan Cronenweth obscure most of the background while bringing their characters to the forefront. The color blue may also signify Deckard’s negative emotions toward his job; the film reveals earlier that he has no choice but to take it.

The climactic scene of Blade Runner is an exercise in pure low-key techniques. As the replicant Roy Batty chases Deckard through L.A.’s Bradbury Hotel, what little light there is to be seen seeps in at odd angles and intervals. Consider a shot in which Deckard helplessly tries to find his way out of a room. The windows, from which an odd harsh light emanates, are half boarded up, allowing the light to play across the room in a kind of checkerboard pattern, casting odd shadows across the room and across Harrison Ford. Here, Scott and Cronenweth use low light levels to make it unclear what lurks around the corner, both for Deckard and for the audience.

Ridley Scott, for all his invention and brilliance, does not hold a monopoly on low-key lighting. David Cronenberg, a master of horror, often manipulates light levels and positions to achieve his dramatic goals. In Cronenberg’s The Fly, shot by Mark Irwin, Jeff Goldblum’s character Seth transforms from a human to a bizarre fly-like creature. Though more subtle than Goldblum’s makeup, the film’s lighting also goes through its own transformation. Early in the film, when Seth is fully human, his apartment is lit in the traditional high-key style; everything is fully visible and shadows are minimized. Later, as in the scene where Seth’s girlfriend visits him for the final time, the same set is lit much differently. Seth, in the final throes of his transformation, hides in his bathroom, which is now very dark and obscured. His girlfriend also has harsh shadows across her face. Clearly, low-key lighting is used here to display Seth’s descent into darkness.

Though low-key lighting did not originate in the modern film era, cinematographers like Gordon Ellis, the ‘Prince of Darkness,’ helped to bring low light levels and unusual lighting positions to the forefront. Due in part to his innovations, low-key came to dominate modern films, especially genres like science fiction and horror, where directors like Ridley Scott and David Cronenberg, with their respective cinematographers, used low-key lighting to great effect.

Genesis and the Theogony: A Comparison

In ancient culture, those peoples who mastered agriculture began to have more time to develop thoughts, ideas, and stories. Especially vital to a number of different civilizations was the creation story, an explanation for how and why things had come to be. Comparing and contrasting two different creation stories; in this case, Genesis from the Hebrews and Hesiod’s Theogony from the Greeks, provides a valuable insight into the differing values and circumstances of the peoples who devised these stories.

The relationships between man and nature in the Theogony and Genesis differ in some very interesting ways, but they also share certain similarities. Both, for instance, reveal a love/hate relationship between man and nature present in the two cultures.
Genesis gives two different accounts of the creation of man, both full of positive connotations with nature. In Genesis 1, God spends five of his seven days creating nature in its various forms, such as water, grass, trees, fruit, and animals. Each day of creation ends with the phrase, “and God saw it was good” (39), underscoring the positive feelings toward nature felt by the Hebrews. Furthermore, God creates humans specifically “to hold sway over… all the crawling things” on earth. He also tells the humans “I have given you every seed-bearing plant… yours they will be” (40). The importance of nature to the Hebrews becomes even clearer in Genesis 2, where God fashions “the human, humus, from the soil” (40). Here humans not only are given rights to nature, they are born from it. However, not everything associated with nature is benevolent: Nature also proves to be man’s downfall, as humans are exiled from Eden for eating from a tree “good for eating,” and “lovely to look at” (41).

The Theogony, though differing from Genesis in its portrayal of nature, follows a similar pattern; that is, nature is both man’s great asset and his downfall. Whereas in Genesis, nature is created for humans, this is not the case in the Greek creation story. In the Theogony, Earth, or Gaia, is herself a god, and “the firm seat of all” (786). With this statement, Hesiod acknowledges the essential role of Gaia: human life would not exist without her presence. However, nature is never explicitly given to mortal man as in Genesis. Indeed, instead of offering man nature’s spoils, Zeus keeps them hidden, “never [giving] to ash trees the power of unwearying fire for the good of men” (790). When man receives fire from Prometheus, Zeus punishes man. This fate bears similarity to the tree of knowledge: man is punished for taking advantage of a certain forbidden aspect of nature. Clearly, both the ancient Hebrews and Greeks had a love/hate relationship with nature.

An area where Genesis and the Theogony differ more profoundly is the relationship between humans and their respective deities. Most obvious, and highly significant, is the Hebrews’ one God versus the Greeks’ many gods. This difference creates marked contrast between humans and God or gods in the two creation stories.

In Genesis, God specifically creates humans “in his image” (40) and commands them to “hold sway” over every other life form on the planet. If earth is not created for humans, at the very least God places great value on the human race. Even when he decides to “wipe out the human race” (43), he still spares Noah and his family, showing a great love for the beings he created in his image. Throughout Genesis, God is constantly watchful over humans, appearing in and influencing every tale. Because the God in the Hebrew Bible is the one and only deity, he has no affairs, and is able to concentrate solely on humans, his unique creation. In this way, God exists for humankind.

In the Theogony, the relationship between the gods and humans is worlds apart from that of Genesis. First and foremost, for a creation story, there is remarkably little insight offered into how humans came into being. The first time humans are mentioned is line 535, approximately halfway though the poem, “when gods and mortal men were settling their accounts” (789). Apparently, humans have already existed for some time at this point, alongside the gods. The next and final time the gods and men interact in the Theogony is during an incident in which Prometheus torments Zeus by giving humans the “far-flashing unwearying fire” (790) Zeus had denied them, for which Zeus then punishes the humans. The interaction here is interesting for a number of reasons. First, unlike Genesis, the gods are not especially interested in helping humans. Prometheus gives the humans fire only to upset Zeus, and Zeus punishes the humans, even though it is Prometheus who committed the crime against him. Here we see the effect of having multiple gods come into play: the gods, here and throughout the story, seem more concerned with each other than with humans. In fact, their interaction with humans seems to be incidental, and certainly not always positive.

Finally, both creation stories provide an interesting viewpoint on the relationships between men and women at the beginning of their respective civilizations. Here, the attitudes of the Hebrews and Greeks are more in alignment, establishing mentalities in which women are somehow inferior to men. However, the harshness with which each culture judges women varies.

The role of Eve in Genesis is a complex one. She is originally referred to by God as a “sustainer” (40) for man. On one hand, the role of sustainer appears to be a vital one; if man is not sustained, the human race will be over as soon as it began. On the other hand, it should not be ignored that Eve is being created for the man. This second, less positive idea is reinforced by the fact Eve is created from a rib of the man, and is thus a part of him. Further complexity is added when Eve eats from the tree of knowledge. It is significant that it is she, and not man, who brings about the fall of humanity. However, the blame does not lie entirely with her: she is convinced to eat the apple by the serpent, “the most cunning of all the beasts” (41) that God created. God takes note of this and punishes the serpent, but tells man that he is being punished “because you listened to the voice of your wife” (42). Eve, and thus woman, emerges from Genesis not condemned as evil, but not without dependence on man and not without blame for the fall.

Compared to Eve, the role of women in the Theogony is simple. When Zeus saw humans using the fire stolen by Prometheus, he “contrived an evil for man.” This evil, created from “dreaded beasts” (790), was woman. Lines 585 to 615 of the 929-line Theogony go into extreme detail as to how women are a “tempting snare from which men cannot escape,” and an “evil for mortal men.” It also describes how men who do not marry, “fleeing the malice of women” (791) end up suffering just as much as those who married; perhaps Hesiod deserves credit for our modern phrase, “can’t live with them, can’t live without them.” In any case, the Theogony makes little room for women to emerge as anything but evil.

As the earliest civilizations sat down to write (or sing) about their origins, some fundamental themes developed despite location or other circumstances. Many creation stories from around the world deal with the relationship between humans and nature, dealings with deities, and the role of women. Just as fascinating as the fact these themes were universal is the fact that they were dealt with in such different ways. A comparison of The Hebrews’ Genesis and the Greeks’ Theogony illustrates how emerging civilizations could share fundamental notions about creationism, yet differ widely in other core beliefs.

Editing in Chaplin's The Immigrant

Unlike his contemporary and good friend Buster Keaton, Charlie Chaplin often fused comedy with a social message. The Immigrant, Chaplin’s 1917 film wherein the Tramp faces hard times as an immigrant to America, is no exception. The editing in the restaurant scene of The Immigrant, used largely to reveal, hide, or emphasize certain details, enhances both Chaplin’s comedic punch and his theme of the plight of the recently arrived immigrant.

The restaurant scene in question begins with a cut from the Tramp outdoors, entering the restaurant, to a long shot of the interior of the restaurant, through which Chaplin walks. The long shot serves a dual purpose. First, in a textbook example of the master shot technique, it establishes the location in which the following scene’s action will take place. Comedically, however, the scene is framed so that the Tramp’s signature waddle is in full view.

After Chaplin takes a seat, the film cuts to a tighter shot; Chaplin is seated, centered in the frame, with a waiter to his left and another restaurant-goer to his right. In the ensuing gag, the poor immigrant misunderstands the waiter’s jerked thumb. He believes the waiter is pointing to the man to his right, when he is really telling Chaplin to remove his hat. The gag works so well partly because of the framing. The farthest thing to the right is his fellow patron; when the Tramp thinks he’s being told to look to the right and obliges, the only thing in frame he has to look at is the blissfully ignorant man, humorously slurping up his soup. The wide amount of empty space above Chaplin’s head also comes into play when he looks up to see if his hat was removed from above. For the audience, due to the empty space, it’s comedically clear nothing is above Chaplin.

When this gag has played out, the film cuts to a very brief close up of the woman the Tramp met and fell for earlier in the story. While the shot and its placement in the scene make clear she is in the restaurant, it does not reveal her proximity to Chaplin. Though not expressly comedic, this shot serves to raise the emotional stakes for Chaplin’s character; it is not yet clear whether he will see her and be reunited. It also holds fresh comedic promise for those versed in the works of Chaplin: if indeed reunited, much opportunity for the Tramp to embarrass himself in front of his love interest emerges.

Editing is perhaps used to the greatest comic effect in The Immigrant’s restaurant scene when the Tramp realizes he is short on cash and prepares for a fight. Initially, in long shot, we see the gang of waiters stalk by and exit, while Chaplin begins to prepare himself, shaking his head and taking a few jabs. In a perfectly timed cut, the film enters a medium shot in which Chaplin’s waiter emerges imposingly into the left of the frame, which he fills, while the Tramp takes no notice, and continues jabbing the air. When he finally does take notice, the film cuts to a close up of Chaplin’s reaction: a rather comedic rolling of the eyes in embarrassment and fear.

Most of the comedy in The Immigrant, with the exception of the previous examples, comes from Chaplin, framed rather simply and theatrically, acting out his gags and bits without significant editing. Near the end of the restaurant scene, however, a gag is played out which would be impossible without some relatively quick cutting. The gag begins when an artist spots the Tramp and his girlfriend. He begins to paint the air. This is followed by a cut to The Tramp and his girlfriend, who look at each other, then back to the artist, who appears to create binoculars with his hands. Finally, there is another cut to Chaplin, who mimics the artist’s action with a pair of salt and pepper shakers. These four successive cuts take place in just a few seconds, a high contrast to the rest of the film, which is made up largely of long takes. Aside from establishing the distance between the artist and the Tramp (and thus justifying the binoculars), Chaplin’s quick cutting increases the perceived pace and allows the Tramp’s makeshift binoculars to come out of nowhere, infinitely increasing their humor.

As noted previously, comedy was not Chaplin’s only aim as an actor and director. As was usually the case in Chaplin’s films, The Immigrant uses comedy as a vehicle for a social message. The Immigrant, in specific, deals with the plight of newcomers to America, who, in Chaplin’s view, do not always receive all the liberties promised to them. The editing of the restaurant scene helps to enhance this theme.

The first significant edit relating to the plight of the immigrant comes during the Tramp’s peculiar style of bean eating. As he switches from eating one bean at a time to shoveling knife-fulls into his mouth, much to the dismay of the fine American gentleman next to him, there is a cut to the restaurant’s source of music: a pianist and a violinist who play very regally. After this shot, which lasts only a few seconds, the film returns to Chaplin, who is now in the process of eating bread improperly, and causing the gentleman next to him to storm off. The absurdity with which Chaplin eats is in itself comedic, but contrasting his foreign eating habits with his more sophisticated and proper surroundings gives it social meaning as well. As indicted by the earlier title card, the immigrant Tramp is simply “hungry and broke,” but because he does not yet understand the eating habits of his new country, he incites dismay.

Frequent contrasts are made in the scene between those who can afford food and those who cannot. Near the end of the scene, the Tramp and his love interest are approached by the artist who wishes to paint them. When he asks the waiter to bring his check to the Tramp’s table, Chaplin chooses to cut to the artist’s table as the waiter walks over to it to find the check. This minor action has no real bearing on the plot, nor is comedic. Rather, the cut between the immigrant’s table and the established American artist’s table provides an excellent contrast. On the Tramp’s table, we can see a coffee cup, salt and pepper shakers, and used dishes swept off to the side. These items are not shown in close up, but Chaplin calls attention to them by placing his arm in several of them. The film cuts to the artist’s table. A plethora of items cover the table. When the film cuts back to the Tramp’s table, it seems barren by comparison, contrasting an immigrant’s paltry sum of money with an natural born citizen’s.

Although not particularly championed for his editing ability, it is clear Charles Chaplin used editing to accomplish multiple tasks. Although his editing is more subtle than that of his contemporaries, Chaplin’s editing skills are undoubtedly another asset in both netting laughs and furthering his social message.