Thursday, April 27, 2006

Genesis and the Theogony: A Comparison

In ancient culture, those peoples who mastered agriculture began to have more time to develop thoughts, ideas, and stories. Especially vital to a number of different civilizations was the creation story, an explanation for how and why things had come to be. Comparing and contrasting two different creation stories; in this case, Genesis from the Hebrews and Hesiod’s Theogony from the Greeks, provides a valuable insight into the differing values and circumstances of the peoples who devised these stories.

The relationships between man and nature in the Theogony and Genesis differ in some very interesting ways, but they also share certain similarities. Both, for instance, reveal a love/hate relationship between man and nature present in the two cultures.
Genesis gives two different accounts of the creation of man, both full of positive connotations with nature. In Genesis 1, God spends five of his seven days creating nature in its various forms, such as water, grass, trees, fruit, and animals. Each day of creation ends with the phrase, “and God saw it was good” (39), underscoring the positive feelings toward nature felt by the Hebrews. Furthermore, God creates humans specifically “to hold sway over… all the crawling things” on earth. He also tells the humans “I have given you every seed-bearing plant… yours they will be” (40). The importance of nature to the Hebrews becomes even clearer in Genesis 2, where God fashions “the human, humus, from the soil” (40). Here humans not only are given rights to nature, they are born from it. However, not everything associated with nature is benevolent: Nature also proves to be man’s downfall, as humans are exiled from Eden for eating from a tree “good for eating,” and “lovely to look at” (41).

The Theogony, though differing from Genesis in its portrayal of nature, follows a similar pattern; that is, nature is both man’s great asset and his downfall. Whereas in Genesis, nature is created for humans, this is not the case in the Greek creation story. In the Theogony, Earth, or Gaia, is herself a god, and “the firm seat of all” (786). With this statement, Hesiod acknowledges the essential role of Gaia: human life would not exist without her presence. However, nature is never explicitly given to mortal man as in Genesis. Indeed, instead of offering man nature’s spoils, Zeus keeps them hidden, “never [giving] to ash trees the power of unwearying fire for the good of men” (790). When man receives fire from Prometheus, Zeus punishes man. This fate bears similarity to the tree of knowledge: man is punished for taking advantage of a certain forbidden aspect of nature. Clearly, both the ancient Hebrews and Greeks had a love/hate relationship with nature.

An area where Genesis and the Theogony differ more profoundly is the relationship between humans and their respective deities. Most obvious, and highly significant, is the Hebrews’ one God versus the Greeks’ many gods. This difference creates marked contrast between humans and God or gods in the two creation stories.

In Genesis, God specifically creates humans “in his image” (40) and commands them to “hold sway” over every other life form on the planet. If earth is not created for humans, at the very least God places great value on the human race. Even when he decides to “wipe out the human race” (43), he still spares Noah and his family, showing a great love for the beings he created in his image. Throughout Genesis, God is constantly watchful over humans, appearing in and influencing every tale. Because the God in the Hebrew Bible is the one and only deity, he has no affairs, and is able to concentrate solely on humans, his unique creation. In this way, God exists for humankind.

In the Theogony, the relationship between the gods and humans is worlds apart from that of Genesis. First and foremost, for a creation story, there is remarkably little insight offered into how humans came into being. The first time humans are mentioned is line 535, approximately halfway though the poem, “when gods and mortal men were settling their accounts” (789). Apparently, humans have already existed for some time at this point, alongside the gods. The next and final time the gods and men interact in the Theogony is during an incident in which Prometheus torments Zeus by giving humans the “far-flashing unwearying fire” (790) Zeus had denied them, for which Zeus then punishes the humans. The interaction here is interesting for a number of reasons. First, unlike Genesis, the gods are not especially interested in helping humans. Prometheus gives the humans fire only to upset Zeus, and Zeus punishes the humans, even though it is Prometheus who committed the crime against him. Here we see the effect of having multiple gods come into play: the gods, here and throughout the story, seem more concerned with each other than with humans. In fact, their interaction with humans seems to be incidental, and certainly not always positive.

Finally, both creation stories provide an interesting viewpoint on the relationships between men and women at the beginning of their respective civilizations. Here, the attitudes of the Hebrews and Greeks are more in alignment, establishing mentalities in which women are somehow inferior to men. However, the harshness with which each culture judges women varies.

The role of Eve in Genesis is a complex one. She is originally referred to by God as a “sustainer” (40) for man. On one hand, the role of sustainer appears to be a vital one; if man is not sustained, the human race will be over as soon as it began. On the other hand, it should not be ignored that Eve is being created for the man. This second, less positive idea is reinforced by the fact Eve is created from a rib of the man, and is thus a part of him. Further complexity is added when Eve eats from the tree of knowledge. It is significant that it is she, and not man, who brings about the fall of humanity. However, the blame does not lie entirely with her: she is convinced to eat the apple by the serpent, “the most cunning of all the beasts” (41) that God created. God takes note of this and punishes the serpent, but tells man that he is being punished “because you listened to the voice of your wife” (42). Eve, and thus woman, emerges from Genesis not condemned as evil, but not without dependence on man and not without blame for the fall.

Compared to Eve, the role of women in the Theogony is simple. When Zeus saw humans using the fire stolen by Prometheus, he “contrived an evil for man.” This evil, created from “dreaded beasts” (790), was woman. Lines 585 to 615 of the 929-line Theogony go into extreme detail as to how women are a “tempting snare from which men cannot escape,” and an “evil for mortal men.” It also describes how men who do not marry, “fleeing the malice of women” (791) end up suffering just as much as those who married; perhaps Hesiod deserves credit for our modern phrase, “can’t live with them, can’t live without them.” In any case, the Theogony makes little room for women to emerge as anything but evil.

As the earliest civilizations sat down to write (or sing) about their origins, some fundamental themes developed despite location or other circumstances. Many creation stories from around the world deal with the relationship between humans and nature, dealings with deities, and the role of women. Just as fascinating as the fact these themes were universal is the fact that they were dealt with in such different ways. A comparison of The Hebrews’ Genesis and the Greeks’ Theogony illustrates how emerging civilizations could share fundamental notions about creationism, yet differ widely in other core beliefs.

No comments:

Post a Comment