Thursday, April 27, 2006

Editing in Chaplin's The Immigrant

Unlike his contemporary and good friend Buster Keaton, Charlie Chaplin often fused comedy with a social message. The Immigrant, Chaplin’s 1917 film wherein the Tramp faces hard times as an immigrant to America, is no exception. The editing in the restaurant scene of The Immigrant, used largely to reveal, hide, or emphasize certain details, enhances both Chaplin’s comedic punch and his theme of the plight of the recently arrived immigrant.

The restaurant scene in question begins with a cut from the Tramp outdoors, entering the restaurant, to a long shot of the interior of the restaurant, through which Chaplin walks. The long shot serves a dual purpose. First, in a textbook example of the master shot technique, it establishes the location in which the following scene’s action will take place. Comedically, however, the scene is framed so that the Tramp’s signature waddle is in full view.

After Chaplin takes a seat, the film cuts to a tighter shot; Chaplin is seated, centered in the frame, with a waiter to his left and another restaurant-goer to his right. In the ensuing gag, the poor immigrant misunderstands the waiter’s jerked thumb. He believes the waiter is pointing to the man to his right, when he is really telling Chaplin to remove his hat. The gag works so well partly because of the framing. The farthest thing to the right is his fellow patron; when the Tramp thinks he’s being told to look to the right and obliges, the only thing in frame he has to look at is the blissfully ignorant man, humorously slurping up his soup. The wide amount of empty space above Chaplin’s head also comes into play when he looks up to see if his hat was removed from above. For the audience, due to the empty space, it’s comedically clear nothing is above Chaplin.

When this gag has played out, the film cuts to a very brief close up of the woman the Tramp met and fell for earlier in the story. While the shot and its placement in the scene make clear she is in the restaurant, it does not reveal her proximity to Chaplin. Though not expressly comedic, this shot serves to raise the emotional stakes for Chaplin’s character; it is not yet clear whether he will see her and be reunited. It also holds fresh comedic promise for those versed in the works of Chaplin: if indeed reunited, much opportunity for the Tramp to embarrass himself in front of his love interest emerges.

Editing is perhaps used to the greatest comic effect in The Immigrant’s restaurant scene when the Tramp realizes he is short on cash and prepares for a fight. Initially, in long shot, we see the gang of waiters stalk by and exit, while Chaplin begins to prepare himself, shaking his head and taking a few jabs. In a perfectly timed cut, the film enters a medium shot in which Chaplin’s waiter emerges imposingly into the left of the frame, which he fills, while the Tramp takes no notice, and continues jabbing the air. When he finally does take notice, the film cuts to a close up of Chaplin’s reaction: a rather comedic rolling of the eyes in embarrassment and fear.

Most of the comedy in The Immigrant, with the exception of the previous examples, comes from Chaplin, framed rather simply and theatrically, acting out his gags and bits without significant editing. Near the end of the restaurant scene, however, a gag is played out which would be impossible without some relatively quick cutting. The gag begins when an artist spots the Tramp and his girlfriend. He begins to paint the air. This is followed by a cut to The Tramp and his girlfriend, who look at each other, then back to the artist, who appears to create binoculars with his hands. Finally, there is another cut to Chaplin, who mimics the artist’s action with a pair of salt and pepper shakers. These four successive cuts take place in just a few seconds, a high contrast to the rest of the film, which is made up largely of long takes. Aside from establishing the distance between the artist and the Tramp (and thus justifying the binoculars), Chaplin’s quick cutting increases the perceived pace and allows the Tramp’s makeshift binoculars to come out of nowhere, infinitely increasing their humor.

As noted previously, comedy was not Chaplin’s only aim as an actor and director. As was usually the case in Chaplin’s films, The Immigrant uses comedy as a vehicle for a social message. The Immigrant, in specific, deals with the plight of newcomers to America, who, in Chaplin’s view, do not always receive all the liberties promised to them. The editing of the restaurant scene helps to enhance this theme.

The first significant edit relating to the plight of the immigrant comes during the Tramp’s peculiar style of bean eating. As he switches from eating one bean at a time to shoveling knife-fulls into his mouth, much to the dismay of the fine American gentleman next to him, there is a cut to the restaurant’s source of music: a pianist and a violinist who play very regally. After this shot, which lasts only a few seconds, the film returns to Chaplin, who is now in the process of eating bread improperly, and causing the gentleman next to him to storm off. The absurdity with which Chaplin eats is in itself comedic, but contrasting his foreign eating habits with his more sophisticated and proper surroundings gives it social meaning as well. As indicted by the earlier title card, the immigrant Tramp is simply “hungry and broke,” but because he does not yet understand the eating habits of his new country, he incites dismay.

Frequent contrasts are made in the scene between those who can afford food and those who cannot. Near the end of the scene, the Tramp and his love interest are approached by the artist who wishes to paint them. When he asks the waiter to bring his check to the Tramp’s table, Chaplin chooses to cut to the artist’s table as the waiter walks over to it to find the check. This minor action has no real bearing on the plot, nor is comedic. Rather, the cut between the immigrant’s table and the established American artist’s table provides an excellent contrast. On the Tramp’s table, we can see a coffee cup, salt and pepper shakers, and used dishes swept off to the side. These items are not shown in close up, but Chaplin calls attention to them by placing his arm in several of them. The film cuts to the artist’s table. A plethora of items cover the table. When the film cuts back to the Tramp’s table, it seems barren by comparison, contrasting an immigrant’s paltry sum of money with an natural born citizen’s.

Although not particularly championed for his editing ability, it is clear Charles Chaplin used editing to accomplish multiple tasks. Although his editing is more subtle than that of his contemporaries, Chaplin’s editing skills are undoubtedly another asset in both netting laughs and furthering his social message.

No comments:

Post a Comment