Sunday, June 3, 2007

Star Trek: The Motion Picture (Director's Edition)

I haven't seen The Motion Picture in years, and never seen the Director's Edition, so I decided to take another look at what I've often called the worst film ever.

First off, let me praise the admirable restraint of Robert Wise. From what I can tell (and it has been years since I've seen the film), Wise changed very little. This Director's Edition has little in common with bloated, excessive recuts like Star Wars (sorry George, seems like I'm picking on you this week). Wise apparently added about 4 minutes of footage to the original cut, and in effect shaved 7 from the "extended TV edition," the only version I've had the displeasure of viewing until now. So for me, it feels like a slightly tighter film.

He also did little to the effects, significantly changing only a few shots. Most of the changes are more subtle, like removing Vulcan's moons for continuity purposes.

The original 1979 effects, produced in a rush by Douglas Trumball, are actually quite impressive, especially the interior of V'Ger. Having little in common with other Trek models, it reminds me more of Alien or Blade Runner.

Though the film feels slightly tighter, pacing is still a major problem. I prayed Wise would cut down certain infamous scenes, but they still exist in disgruntling laborous form. Kirk and Scotty's trip to the Enterprise still clocks in at five minutes. Five minutes of cutting back and forth from the Enterprise to Kirk's shining face. He's happy to see her again. We get it.

It's entirely possible a good film just isn't possible given the story provided. Simply put, very little happens. The villian, as it were, lacks personality, or, y'know, villiany. There's an interesting dynamic between the old and new crew members, but it never reaches a breaking point and isn't volatile enough to provide good tension. Spock's eventual realization that pure logic isn't enough is ironic, because the film itself lacks feeling.

That is, with the exception of the awesome score by Jerry Goldsmith. The main theme he composed for this film went on to become the theme for Next Generation, so it's slightly jarring to hear it in a TOS film, but it's flat out awesome nonetheless. So is a piece I thought was written for Star Trek II, but it's actually used first here as "Ilia's Love Theme."

So, still a pretty flawed film. Slightly better than I remember, though.

Here's the most boring trailer ever cut. Narrated by Orson Welles! I like how he says "Persis Kham. Bat! Ta."

No comments:

Post a Comment